• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
Revive

Revive

The coalition for grouse moor reform

  • Why REVIVE?
    • Land Reform
    • Scotland’s Grouse Moors
    • Snaring & Trapping
    • Mountain Hare Culling
    • Fewer Jobs
    • Mass outdoor medication
    • Public health
    • Environmental Damage
    • Killing protected birds of prey
    • Tracks, roads and fencing
  • The Coalition
  • News & Events
  • Get Involved
  • Videos & Media
  • Contact
  • Publications
  • Bluesky
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

A Better Way: How an Alternative to Grouse Moors could help tackle climate change, increase biodiversity and benefit Scotland’s people

February 21, 2020 by Editor

February 21, 2020 by Editor

Max Wiszniewski, Campaign Manager for 'Revive: the coalition for grouse moor reform', introduces the group's new report which makes the case for grouse moor reform to tackle climate change.

THE WORLD is in an era of climate crisis and solutions are being desperately sought after by movements, and some governments, around the globe.

The Scottish Government in particular, would say its climate targets are world leading and while some would commend them or argue that their ambitions should be stronger, reaching these targets either way will require decisive and immediate action. They will require the vision and bravery to stand up against (currently) powerful vested interests.

These interests often maintain their power by telling us that there are no alternatives to their way of doing things, that what we have now is as good as it gets, then use their lobbying power to make brave initiatives mediocre.

Whether made by fossil fuel industries, big business or large landowners, this process is designed to drain the hope in people, but momentum can be overwhelming and an idea whose time has come is unstoppable. The Revive movement, whose aim is to transform Scotland’s grouse moors, has arrived at the right moment with a vision to change the face of Scotland for the better.

Muir burn

Huge swathes of Scotland are dominated by grouse moor management and they are known to cause environmental damage to much of our land. Muirburn is a process where heather is burnt in patches or strips on a mass-scale, to make the environment more suitable for maintaining grouse at unnaturally high numbers. The more intensively managed the land is, the more grouse there are for sport shooting and the more environmental damage that ensues.

Revive commissioned an independent report, A Better Way, by an expert in sustainable land management, Dr Helen Armstrong, to look at this issue and it found that around “328,000 ha (4% of Scotland’s land area) is regularly strip burned to support grouse shooting”. Much of this burning happens on our vital peatland – Scotland’s Amazon Rainforest.

Peatland in Scotland stores almost 25 times as much carbon as all trees and plants in the UK – in fact, if all the carbon stored by Scotland’s peatlands were released at once that would be the equivalent of over 140 years’ of Scotland’s current carbon emissions. Yet around 40% of the total burned area for grouse in Scotland overlies deep peat (with a depth of 50 cm or more).

If deep peat is sensibly redefined to be at a depth of 25cm, as many are calling for, the picture of damage could be even bleaker. When peat is degraded its ability to store carbon is diminished and it can instead release it into the atmosphere. Decision-makers will soon have to decide if a few extra grouse for sport shooting are worth the environmental cost.

What is more, our Better Way report finds that “grouse moors, both burned and unburned, are lower in structural and species diversity, are less biologically productive and provide fewer ecosystem services than the woodlands, scrub and peat-forming bogs that could replace them”.

A widescale change from the monoculture of intensive grouse moor management towards a more sustainable and diverse wooded landscape would not only stop the current environmental damage, it would be a gamechanger in the fight against catastrophic biodiversity loss and for the sequestration of carbon.

This transition would also make our country less volatile and more resilient to the effects of climate change in the future. Moreover, a transition away from driven grouse shooting would end the wider circle of destruction that surrounds the industry.

Ending driven grouse shooting would stop the snaring, trapping and killing of untold thousands of mountain hares, foxes, stoats, weasels and crows in the name of increasing grouse numbers for sport shooting.

Ending driven grouse shooting would stop our countryside being polluted by tens of thousands of medicated grit stations which keep grouse numbers unnaturally high before thousands of tons of lead shot are spread across the landscape.

Ending driven grouse shooting would be a significant step in ending the illegal persecution of Scotland’s birds of prey which, like other wildlife, bring many tourists to our country.

If the Scottish government can’t commit to ending driven grouse shooting, it can take the sensible and necessary steps to end the circle of destruction, the unsustainable elements that surround it.

Grouse moors therefore, sometimes seen as an unsurmountable problem can be radically transformed into an immense opportunity for our wildlife, the environment but also our people.

For all the land they use up (somewhere between 12-18% of Scotland – nobody really knows, but it’s a lot) grouse moor management only contributes around 0.02% of Scotland’s economy (GVA) – or about £23 million.

The opportunity for communities to use (and own) the land better is enormous. Forestry alone provides several times more jobs and a much larger economic impact than grouse shooting.

It’s clear that land currently used for grouse shooting is a perfect target in the war against climate change. Far from costing jobs, A Better Way finds that a just transition away from driven grouse moors could actually improve employment prospects, while helping the government meet their climate targets on time.

Revive launched just over a year ago and 15,000 people have already joined the movement to change the face of Scotland. With grouse moors being scrutinised by parliament amidst the current political climate and the growing calls for transformational land reform, it seems that the movement has arrived at the right time – but time is precious.

We may only have one parliamentary term left to act – not before we take action – and this will require the vision and bravery to stand up against those (currently) powerful vested interests.

As the Scottish Parliament looks at ways to reform Scotland’s grouse moors, we call on them to be brave. The momentum for this change is overwhelming and if we achieve it the growing hope can replace the despair and lead to a braver future for us all.

This article was first published on CommonSpace.scot

You can read and download A Better Way here

« New Revive report sent to every MSP in Scotland
Taking over a former driven grouse moor »

Filed Under: News Tagged With: A Better Way, environmental damage

Copyright © 2026 Revive

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. More info Accept
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT